Proposal would rate more students advanced for the same test scores and cloud comparisons with prior years
WASHINGTON, D.C. – Democrats for Education Reform (DFER) today urged the Pennsylvania State Board of Education to reject a proposal that would lower the state’s standard for advanced performance on math and reading tests.
Under the Pennsylvania Department of Education’s proposal, which the board is expected to vote on Nov. 19, the minimum score needed to be rated advanced on PSSA math and reading would fall in nearly every grade. A student scoring just below today’s advanced cutoff could be rated advanced under the new thresholds without earning a single additional point, and department officials told the board the change would increase the number of students in that category. The proficiency cutoff would stay at 1,000, but the department’s own presentation says the change would also affect the share of students rated below basic. Comparisons with prior years would become difficult, leaving families and educators without a clear read on whether achievement is rising or falling.
“We need to raise the bar and raise expectations, not lower them,” said Jorge Elorza, CEO of DFER. “Lowering the cutoff score so more students are rated advanced is like widening the goalposts. The same field goal that went wide right yesterday is counted as three points today. Calling more students advanced does not mean more students have mastered advanced work, and families deserve labels that mean what they say. The State Board should reject this proposal, release this year’s results on the existing scale and revisit cut scores once Pennsylvania adopts the new math and reading standards the department says are coming.”
Pennsylvania last reset its math and reading cut scores in 2015 to align its tests with the more rigorous PA Core Standards. Department officials now say those thresholds are overdue for an update, even though new math and reading standards remain years away by the department’s own estimate. The proposal would cover both the PSSA and the high school Keystone exams students took this spring, and it follows a science cut score change the board approved in September only after that subject’s standards were overhauled.
In Philadelphia, the review has also held up results families rely on. State officials have acknowledged that the cut score review contributed to the months-long delay in releasing Philadelphia’s scores, which families typically receive in August. With applications to the city’s selective high schools due Dec. 16, families still do not know whether their children qualify for some admissions lotteries.
The State Board of Education is expected to take up the proposal at its Nov. 19 meeting in Harrisburg. If the board approves it, the department plans to share final school-level results with districts within days. Statewide results are expected in early 2027, according to Education Secretary Carrie Rowe.
###
Democrats for Education Reform is a national political organization that supports Democratic leaders and candidates who champion innovative policies that expand opportunity, address inequities and improve outcomes for students.