Advanced Still Means Advanced: DFER Applauds Pennsylvania State Board Vote

Featured DFER Press Release by DFER

November 19, 2026

For Immediate Release

November 18, 2026

For Contact

press@dfer.org

The vote keeps Pennsylvania’s existing cut scores on state math and reading tests, but Philadelphia families are still waiting on results from tests students took this spring

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Pennsylvania will keep its existing performance standards on state tests after the State Board of Education rejected a proposal to change them, a decision Democrats for Education Reform (DFER) applauded today.

The vote leaves the existing math and reading thresholds in place for the PSSA and Keystone exams. Department officials had planned to share final school-level results with districts within days of approving new cut scores, with statewide results expected in early 2027. With no new thresholds to wait on, the department can score this spring’s tests on the existing scale. In Philadelphia, families applying to the city’s selective high schools face a Dec. 16 deadline and still do not know whether their children qualify for some admissions lotteries.

“The State Board kept the bar where it belongs, and Pennsylvania students are better off for it,” said Jorge Elorza, CEO of DFER. “An advanced score should reflect advanced work. Students took these tests in the spring, and Philadelphia families need the results to choose a school by Dec. 16. We urge the department to get those results to families on the existing scale as quickly as possible.”

The department’s proposal would have lowered the minimum score needed to be rated advanced in nearly every grade, and projections presented at the board’s meeting showed it would have shifted the share of students rated proficient as well. Department officials said the thresholds were overdue for an update and that this spring’s move to fully online testing made it the right time to review them, even though new math and reading standards remain years away by the department’s own estimate. Under the existing standards, about one in eight Pennsylvania students in grades 3 through 8 scored advanced in English language arts in 2025, and about one in six did in math. DFER urged the board on Nov. 18 to reject the proposal and release results on the existing scale.

Philadelphia families waiting on 2026 results can follow updates from the School District of Philadelphia’s school selection office.

###

Democrats for Education Reform is a national political organization that supports Democratic leaders and candidates who champion innovative policies that expand opportunity, address inequities and improve outcomes for students.

our newsletter.