This second installment in The Center Square’s three-part school choice series reports that states with existing school choice programs are continuing to opt into the federal Education Freedom Tax Credit, which begins Jan. 1, 2027, with 30 states participating so far. Thirty-three states and Washington, D.C., have some form of school choice, including 23 voucher programs across 13 states and D.C., according to the American Federation for Children. The Lynch Foundation’s Katie Everett called the federal program “the greatest philanthropic opportunity our country has ever seen,” while the AFC’s Ryan Cantrell said it will “supercharge” what state programs offer families. Treasury and the IRS estimate the federal program could support nearly 700 scholarship-granting organizations and generate $26 billion annually by 2030 from over 11 million taxpayers.
With Treasury’s rules now released, supporters are hopeful more Democratic governors will opt in. DFER CEO Jorge Elorza said Democrats have fallen behind both politically and on policy in K-12 education and acknowledged that distrust of the Trump administration may make some governors hesitant, but argued the credit shouldn’t be viewed as inherently conservative or Republican. “Voters are watching. They see that we have been silent on this issue,” Elorza said. “Now there is a political imperative for us to reprioritize and refocus on K-12 education. And it can’t be more of the same. It can’t just be more money to be more of the same. That is not working.”
Implementation challenges received attention too. Children’s Scholarship Fund president Darla Romfo said the program differs from earlier ones because scholarship-granting organizations must convert many small donors, “people who’ve never written a check before to a charity or maybe written a check of $300 or $400,” which is “a whole new exercise” for fundraisers used to larger gifts. National School Choice Awareness Foundation’s Shelby Doyle called the pitch an easy sell: “Hey, this money you were going to pay the federal government in taxes anyway, would you like to give it to someone to have a scholarship for reading tutoring? Who is going to say no to that?” The series concludes Friday with a look at learning outcomes from alternatives to standard public schools.